Depression & Homeopathy : Tom O’Brien MSc. ISHom. Depression & Homeopathy No. 7 in the Mental Health Series of Lectures Depression & Homeopathy
Symptoms of Depression : Symptoms of Depression Appearance - Sad face, slow movements, unkept look
Off Food – loss of interest in food
Weeps continuously or can’t weep – sighing
Unhappy feelings - feeling sad, hopeless, discouraged, or listless
Negative thoughts - "I'm a failure," "I'm no good," "No one cares about me."
Reduced activity - "I just sit around and mope," "Doing anything is just too much of an effort."
Reduced concentration or forgetfulness
People problems - "I don't want anybody to see me," "I feel so lonely."
Guilt and low self-esteem - "It's all my fault," "I should be punished."
Physical problems - Sleeping problems, weight loss or gain, decreased sexual interest, or headaches
Suicidal thoughts or wishes - "I'd be better off dead," "I wonder if it hurts to die."
Causes of Depression : Causes of Depression Imbalance of brain chemicals called neurotransmitters
Certain diseases or illnesses - cancer, heart disease, Parkinson's disease, Alzheimer's disease, diabetes - referred to as co-occurring depression.
Negative thinking patterns
Family history of depression
Difficult life events – death of a loved one, divorce, financial strains, history of trauma, moving to a new location ….
Frequent and excessive alcohol consumption
Resolved / Unresolved Trauma
Slide 4 : Predisposition Intermediate Variables Symptoms Acquired
Disposition Biochemical/
Genetic
Disposition Socio-Cultural
Psycho-Social
Conditions Interaction Patterns
Communication Patterns Acute Symptoms Chronic Symptoms Psycho-physiologic
Response Patterns
Cognitive Style
Risk-Incurring Behaviours
Almost any Life Event / Distress Intra-psychic
Processes Causes of Mental Illness including Depression
Classifications of Mental Illness DSM (USA) / ICD (Eur) : Classifications of Mental Illness DSM (USA) / ICD (Eur) Depression (adjustment)
Anxiety / Neurosis Disorders
Generalised Anxiety Disorder
Phobias; Obsession-Compulsion; Impulse Control
Conversion & Dissociative Disorders
Panic Disorder
Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder
Bipolar Disorder (Enduring) Mood Dysfunction
Schizophrenia (Psychotic) Disorder of Thought
Eating Disorders
Sexual & Gender Disorders
M.I. associated with Ageing; Dementia; Mental Handicap; Substance Abuse.
Suicidal Behaviour
Personality Disorder (A continuum of behavioural ‘reactivity’). Paranoia Hysteria Hypochondriasis Hypochondriasis Paranoia Hysteria Click
Organon : § 215
Almost all the so-called mental and emotional diseases are nothing more than corporeal diseases in which the symptom of derangement of the mind and disposition peculiar to each of them is increased, while the corporeal symptoms decline … almost as though it were a local disease in the invisible subtle organ of the mind or disposition.
§ 216
…so that, in short, the affections of the grosser corporeal organs become, as it were, transferred and conducted to the almost spiritual, mental and emotional organs…
§ 217 §
In these diseases we must be very careful to make ourselves acquainted with … the accurate apprehension of the precise character of the chief symptom, of the peculiar and always predominating state of the mind and disposition … for the purpose of extinguishing the entire disease, among the remedies whose pure effects are known, a homoeopathic medicinal pathogenetic force - that is to say, a remedy which in its list of symptoms displays, with the greatest possible similarity, not only the corporeal morbid symptoms present in the case of disease before us, but also especially this mental and emotional state. (Aph. 5) Hahnemann taught that the totality of the symptoms includes everything related to the:
- general constitution & temperament
- the signs and symptoms
Miasms
Aetiology (befallments)
Exciting & Maintaining Causes
Lifestyle
Susceptability
Suppression; Iatrogenesis Organon
Trauma : Murphy - Mind
HONOR, effects of wounded, (9)
2 aur, 1 carc, 1 cham, 1 ign, 2 lyc, 1 nat-m, 1 nux-v, 3 STAPH, 1 verat Murphy - Children
ABUSED, ailments from being sexual abuse, from (14)
3 ACON, 1 anac, 3 ARN, 3 CARC, 3 IGN, 1 lyc, 2 med, 3 NAT-M, 1 nux-v, 3 OP, 2 plat, 3 SEP, 3 STAPH, 1 thuj Trauma
Emotional Healing & Homeopathy:Treating ‘Depression’ : Emotional Healing & Homeopathy:Treating ‘Depression’ Tom O’Brien MSc., ISHom.
Key Remedies…….. : Mania
Hyoscyamus
Belladonna
Stramonium
Veratrum Album Key Remedies…….. Arsenicum album
Aurum metallicum
Calcarea carbonica
Causticum
Kali Phosphoricum
Natrum Muriaticum
Ambra Grisea
Sepia
Ignatia Amara
Staphysagria
Pulsatilla
Cimicifuga ‘Befallments’
Key Remedies : Mania
Hyoscyamus
Belladonna
Stramonium
Veratrum Album Key Remedies Arsenicum album
Aurum metallicum
Calcarea carbonica
Causticum
Kali Phosphoricum
Natrum Muriaticum
Ambra Grisea
Sepia
Ignatia Amara
Staphysagria
Pulsatilla
Cimicifuga M
I
N
E
R
A
L
S
Key Remedies : Key Remedies Arsenicum album
Aurum metallicum
Calcarea carbonica
Causticum
Kali Phosphoricum
Natrum Muriaticum
Ambra Grisea
Sepia
Ignatia Amara
Staphysagria
Pulsatilla
Cimicifuga A
N
I
M
A
L
Key Remedies : Key Remedies Arsenicum album
Aurum metallicum
Calcarea carbonica
Causticum
Kali Phosphoricum
Natrum Muriaticum
Ambra Grisea
Sepia
Ignatia Amara
Staphysagria
Pulsatilla
Cimicifuga P
L
A
N
T
S
Miasms : Miasms Primarily… 25 Under-functioning… Psora
Plants : Plants Tom O’Brien MSc., ISHom.
Slide 15 : Wherever possible begin with plant remedies …..
Ignatia Amara: : Ignatia Amara: Remedies Sensitive people who suffer grief or disappointment and try to keep the hurt inside. Wanting not to cry or appear too vulnerable to others, they may seem guarded, defensive, and moody. They may also burst out laughing, or into hysterical tears, for no apparent reason.
A feeling of a lump in the throat and heaviness in the chest with frequent sighing or yawning are strong indications for Ignatia.
Insomnia or excessive sleeping are also often seen. Pine
Willow
Chicory
Staphysagria:‘Frustrated’ : Staphysagria:‘Frustrated’ Quiet, sensitive, emotional people who have difficulty standing up for themselves may benefit from this remedy.
Frustration over hurt feelings, shame, resentment, and suppressed emotions such as anger can lead to depression.
Under too much pressure, they can sometimes lose their natural inhibition and fly into rages or throw things. Unable to sleep at night,
Stomach-aches that are stress-related. Remedies Crab Apple
Gentian
Mimulus
Star of Bethlehem
Pulsatilla: ‘Mama’ (Dependant) : Pulsatilla: ‘Mama’ (Dependant) People who needs this remedy have a childlike softness and sensitivity—and can also be whiny, jealous, and moody.
When depressed, they are sad and tearful, wanting a lot of attention and comforting.
Depression around the time of hormonal changes can often be helped with Pulsatilla.
Crying, fresh air, and gentle exercise improve their mood. Getting too warm stuffy can increase anxiety. Remedies
Cimicifuga: : Cimicifuga: A person who needs this remedy can be energetic and talkative when feeling well, but upset and gloomy when depressed—with exaggerated fears (of insanity, of being attacked, of disaster).
Painful menstrual periods and headaches that involve the neck are often seen when this remedy is needed. Remedies Honeysuckle
Mustard
Metal/Minerals : Metal/Minerals Tom O’Brien MSc., ISHom.
Aurum metallicum: : Aurum metallicum: This remedy can be helpful to serious people, strongly focused on work and achievement, who become depressed if they feel they have failed in some way.
Discouragement, self-reproach, humiliation, and anger can lead to feelings of emptiness and worthlessness.
The person may feel worse at night, with nightmares or insomnia. Remedies Larch
Oak
Pine
Sweet Chestnut
Mustard
Arsenicum album:‘The Death of the Body’ : Arsenicum album:‘The Death of the Body’ Anxious, insecure, perfectionistic people who set high standards for themselves and others
Depressed if their expectations are not met.
Worry about material security sometimes borders on despair.
When feeling ill, these people can be demanding and dependent, even suspicious of others, fearing their condition could be serious, (as if serious illness). Remedies MIND - ANGUISH - driving from place to place - restlessness, with
ACON. ARS. ARS-I. BISM.
Calcarea carbonica:‘Fear of Leaving the Shell’ : A dependable, industrious person who becomes easily overwhelmed from too much worry, work, or physical illness may benefit from this remedy.
Anxiety, fatigue, confusion, discouragement, self-pity, and a despondent dread of disaster may develop.
A person who needs this remedy often feels chilly and sluggish and easily tires on exertion (and may be overweight) Remedies Elm
Oak
Sweet Chestnut
Cherry Plum
Mimulus Calcarea carbonica:‘Fear of Leaving the Shell’
Causticum:‘Damacles Sword’ : Causticum:‘Damacles Sword’ A person who feels depressed because of grief and loss (either recent or over time) may benefit from this remedy.
Frequent crying or a feeling of mental dullness and forgetfulness (with anxious checking to see if the door is locked, if the stove is off, etc.) are other indications.
People who need this remedy are often deeply sympathetic toward others and, having a strong sense of justice, can be deeply discouraged or angry about the world. Remedies
Kali phosphoricum:‘Burnout’ : Kali phosphoricum:‘Burnout’ If a person feels depressed after working too hard, being physically ill, or going through prolonged emotional stress or excitement, this remedy can be helpful.
Exhausted, nervous, and jumpy, they may have difficulty working or concentrating—and become discouraged and lose confidence.
Headaches from mental effort, sensitivity to cold, anemia, insomnia, and indigestion are often seen when this remedy is needed. Remedies See kalis
Slide 26 :
Natrum muriaticum: : Natrum muriaticum: People who need this remedy seem reserved, responsible, and private—yet have strong inner feelings (grief, romantic attachment, anger, or fear of misfortune) that they rarely show.
Can act affronted or angry if someone tries to console them, and need to be alone to cry.
Anxiety, brooding about past grievances, and insomnia can also be experienced when the person is depressed.
A craving for salt and tiredness from sun exposure are other indications for this remedy. Remedies See nats
Relationships : Relationships Tom O’Brien MSc., ISHom.
Slide 29 : THROAT - LUMP; sensation of a - swallowing - amel. - not amel.; swallowing does
agar. androc. ant-c. bamb-a. bar-c. bell. crot-c. gels. hep. Kali-bi. lac-ac. LACH. Nat-m. rumx. Sep.
Other Relationships : Other Relationships Ignatia
Staphysagria
Pulsatilla Acute of Natrum Mur.
Acute of Pulsatilla
Acute of Arsenicum
Animals : Animals Tom O’Brien MSc., ISHom.
Sepia :‘Mother & Woman’ : Sepia :‘Mother & Woman’ People who feel weary, irritable, and indifferent to family members, and worn out by demands of everyday life may need this remedy.
They want to be left alone and may respond in an angry or cutting way if anyone bothers them.
They often feel better from crying, but would rather have others keep their distance and not try to console them or cheer them up.
Menstrual problems, a sagging feeling in internal organs, sluggish digestion, and improvement from vigorous exercise are other indications for this remedy. Remedies
Ambra Grisea‘Inhibited’ : Ambra Grisea‘Inhibited’ The mood of the person who might benefit from Ambra Grisea is very low and endures and there may even be a loathing of life. They cannot bear to have people around and may lock the doors to keep out company. They are likely to be morbid all the time, dwelling on the past and at the same time conscious of every heartbeat (palpitations). Interestingly they can become very talkative having begun to talk. Rigidity of Mind brings on cramps throughout the body. - Time passes slowly.
Modalities
- Worse, music; presence of strangers; from any unusual thing; morning, warm room.
- Better, slow motion in open air; lying on painful part; cold drinks. Remedies r
Rubrics : Rubrics Tom O’Brien MSc., ISHom.
Keys to Rubrics foundfrom the symptoms of ‘Depression’ : Keys to Rubrics foundfrom the symptoms of ‘Depression’ Appearance - Sad face, slow movements, unkept look
Unhappy feelings - feeling sad, hopeless, discouraged, or listless
Negative thoughts - "I'm a failure," "I'm no good," "No one cares about me."
Reduced activity - "I just sit around and mope," "Doing anything is just too much of an effort."
Reduced concentration or forgetfulness
People problems - "I don't want anybody to see me," "I feel so lonely."
Guilt and low self-esteem - "It's all my fault," "I should be punished."
Physical problems - Sleeping problems, weight loss or gain, decreased sexual interest, or head aches
Suicidal thoughts or wishes - "I'd be better off dead," "I wonder if it hurts to die."
Keys to Rubrics foundfrom side-effects of ‘Medicines’ : Keys to Rubrics foundfrom side-effects of ‘Medicines’ Dry mouth
Constipation
Bladder problems
Sexual problems
Blurred vision
Dizziness
Drowsiness as a daytime problem
The newer antidepressants can have other side effects:
Headache
Nausea
Nervousness and insomnia (trouble sleeping / waking often)
Agitation (feeling jittery)
A strategy to begin with… : A strategy to begin with… Take the case
Give the similimum remedy if clearly indicated
Options
30c followed by 200c then higher if needed
Or LMs
Make sure it covers the miasm (usually psora)
Otherwise (… e.g. in an acute stage)
Start with
Aconite followed by
One of the main psoric remedies 30C (Repeated)
and / or Tissue Salts or Bach Flowers
Deal with physical fatigue if present.
Fundamentals in prescribing for the patient with a mental health problem : Fundamentals in prescribing for the patient with a mental health problem Establish the constitutional type and remedy
Note the dominant Miasm
In general acute prescribing: Low Potencies - repeated C’s (up to 200) or LMs
In enduring (chronic) problems – Single dose high potency – don’t repeat often.
Remember that well-selected remedies are nevertheless not always indicated at that time – so treat incurrent states if needed before constitution.
Replace non-prescribed ‘medicine cabinet’ pills with remedies for acute use
Tissue salts
Organ support remedies / tinctures
Nutritional support
Nosodes as intercurrents if the constitutional stops working
Regular follow-up & educate
Recommend Psychotherapy when needed.
Types of Psychotherapy : Types of Psychotherapy Analytical
Freudian / Neo-Freudian
Jungian
Behavioural
Cognitive-Behavioural
Systemic / Constructivist
NLP
Brief Therapy
Psycho-synthesis
Integrative
Person- Centred
Rogerian
Integrative
Process –Oriented
Trans-Personal
Slide 40 : So! What do I do…….
Hysteria & Hypochondria & Paranoia : Depression (adjustment)
Anxiety / Neurosis Disorders
Generalised Anxiety Disorder
Phobias; Obsession-Compulsion; Impulse Control
Conversion & Dissociative Disorders
Panic Disorder
Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder
Bipolar Disorder (Enduring) Mood Dysfunction
Schizophrenia (Psychotic) Disorder of Thought
Eating Disorders
Sexual & Gender Disorders
M.I. associated with Ageing; Dementia; Mental Handicap; Substance Abuse.
Suicidal Behaviour
Personality Disorder (A continuum of behavioural ‘reactivity’). Paranoia Hysteria Hypochondriasis Hypochondriasis Paranoia Hysteria Hysteria & Hypochondria & Paranoia
Effects of Trauma : Effects of Trauma Over and under – reactions
‘Out of the present’ - Dissociation
Repetition (‘stuckness’)
Double binds that hinder healing
Making a career of victimisation
Failures of healing…
Grief & Loss – Aspects of Grieving : Grief & Loss – Aspects of Grieving Denial
Bargaining
Anger
Despair
Acceptance ANGER WITH GRIEF (17)
2 acon, 1 ars, 1 aur, 1 bell, 1 cham, 2 chin, 2 coloc, 1 hyos, 3 IGN, 3 LYC, 2 nat-m, 1 nux-v, 2 ph-ac, 1 plat, 1 puls, 3 STAPH, 1 carc AILMENTS from death parents or friends, of (15)
1 ambr, 1 ars, 1 calc, 3 CAUST, 3 IGN, 1 kali-br, 1 lac-c, 1 lac-h, 1 lim-b-c, 1 lyc, 1 nit-ac, 1 nux-v, 1 plat, 1 rhod, 1 staph Grief Counselling & Grief Therapy,
A Handbook for the Mental Health Practitioneredge
Worden, William J, Routledge
Grief & Loss - Key tasks in therapy : Grief & Loss - Key tasks in therapy To help develop the ability to experience, express and adjust to painful – grief related changes.
To find effective ways to cope with painful emotional and somatic changes
To establish a continuing relationship with the person who died….
To stay healthy and keep functioning
To re-establish relationships and understand that others may have difficulty empathizing with the grief they experience
To develop a healthy image of oneself and the world Kay
Signs of Depression : Signs of Depression Depression, its causes and how to overcome it.
Shreeve, Caroline. Turnstone Press 1984 Depression, the way out of your prison.
Rowe, Dorothy Pelican 1990 Inertia, feeling drained, off food
Cries continuously or can’t cry; Sighing
Sleep disturbed; no interest in sex
Loss in interest in work; Overwork to escape; Alcohol consumption increased; medication
Neglect personal Hygiene
No reason to exist; believes recovery is impossible
Extreme loneliness; feelings of abandonment
Miasms : Miasms 25
end : end